The Kaiser Family Foundation (KFF) estimates Americans owe at least $220 billion in medical debt. Roughly 14 million adults owe more than $1,000, and about 3 million owe more than $10,000. However, debt is only part of the problem. Many families never let their medical bills become formal debt by emptying savings accounts, cashing in retirement funds, boosting credit-card balances, borrowing from relatives, or tapping home equity first. According to a survey by The Commonwealth Fund, 23% of working-age Americans underpaid medical bills despite having coverage all year. Perhaps more surprising, 66% of these underinsured Americans were covered by employer-sponsored insurance. This is totally unacceptable.
It’s a story guaranteed to make anyone who thinks health insurance provides financial security squirm. “My wife was diagnosed with cancer,” one man wrote on social media. “We had insurance. … We did everything society tells you to do. Go to school, work your whole life, don’t live in debt, save up some money, have retirement accounts, own a home.” Then cancer struck. By his telling, five months of medical bills erased two decades of savings. They drained retirement accounts. They refinanced their home and gave up years of equity. Nobody can fact-check an anonymous post on social media. But the situation it describes is very real.

Oncologists even have a name for it: Financial toxicity. It’s one of the fundamental lies about American healthcare: that having health insurance is the same thing as financial protection against sickness.
Cancer is where the weakness becomes painfully visible
Which is why cancer does such a good job of revealing the gaps in the system. Financial exposure doesn’t stop with one hospital bill. There can be deductibles. Coinsurance. Prescriptions. Imaging. Labs. Surgery. Radiation. Infusion therapy. Specialist visits. Transportation. Lodging. Follow-up surveillance. Then there are costs that don’t show up on an explanation of benefits: lost income.
A patient may cut back hours at work or not work at all. So may a spouse or other family member who steps in to provide care. According to the American Cancer Society, lost income, travel expenses, lodging, childcare, and other nonmedical costs all contribute to a cancer patient’s financial burden. They also note that patients may choose to tap into savings or retirement accounts, borrow money or forego care. One family’s medical exposure can’t be defined by asking “What is the patient’s insurance out-of-pocket maximum?” Ask instead, “What is my family’s financial risk if a loved one becomes seriously ill?” Those are two very different numbers.
Insurance can fail without technically failing
This is the most important point. You can have an insurance company that pays every claim and families can still face financial catastrophe. Just as written, the policy can work exactly as intended. The insurer pays its share. The hospital gets paid. The doctors get paid. The pharmacy gets paid. And nothing is left over for the patient, who ends up financially ruined in the process. It’s the incredible paradox of our healthcare finance system. We’ve built it so that a person can be insured and exposed at the same time.
Twenty-eight percent of adults reported they skipped some type of medical care due to cost in 2024, according to the Federal Reserve. 28% of people faced a large, unexpected medical bill during the previous 12 months. Healthcare costs don’t just stress family budgets; they can harm health. Forty-one percent of working-age adults who put off or skipped care due to costs told the Commonwealth Fund that their health issue got worse because of it. That’s when affordability transitions from an economic concern to a clinical one.
“But they had insurance”
That’s exactly the issue. For years, healthcare debates across America have been dominated by our uninsurance rate. Coverage is important. But insurance coverage alone is not a sufficient measure of whether a healthcare system covers people.
One can have that insurance card and pay a premium every month and still face barriers like deductibles and coinsurance, uncovered services, prescription costs, and annual exposure to the brink of bankruptcy. Don’t forget those pesky billing errors and coverage disputes.
A new 2024 Commonwealth Fund study finds that 45% of insured working-age adults were hit with a bill or copayment for something they thought should have been covered in the prior year. And fully 17% said that an insurer denied coverage for a doctor recommended service. It should make us reconsider how we define the meaning of “covered.”
Medical debt doesn’t tell us what families actually lost
We need to stop treating financial toxicity as collateral damage
Here’s another dirty secret. Imagine a couple incurs $75,000 in medical expenses. They pay those bills by liquidating $40,000 from their savings, taking $20,000 from retirement accounts and borrowing $15,000 against their home. The raw figure of medical debt accounts for only part of their financial stress. The family experiences both. In fact, the Commonwealth Fund found that two in five adults with medical debt had dipped into savings to pay their bills.
More than three- quarters felt that medical debt caused them stress or worry. Which is why stories we hear about families liquidating decades of savings shouldn’t be so easily discounted as anecdotal. We may not know the details of each case. What happened in those cases is well known.
Modern medicine can do extraordinary things.
Advances in targeted cancer therapies. Immunotherapies. Breakthrough diagnostics and treatments that can transform diseases that would have once killed us into chronic conditions we can live with—or even cures. We’ve made great progress. But there’s something terribly wrong about innovating medicine that can add years to life while designing a payment system that can take away decades of earned savings.
Cancer patients shouldn’t have to choose between saving their lives and saving for retirement. Cancer spouses shouldn’t have to choose between saving their partner and losing their home. And Americans who bought insurance shouldn’t find out during the worst day of their lives that insurance doesn’t equal financial protection.
The tweet I read from this family ended in rage. It’s easy to read that and focus on the anger. We should be focusing on why it exists. When hardworking Americans can do everything “right” and still end up penniless because their son, daughter, wife, husband gets cancer, that’s not a sign they didn’t plan appropriately. That’s a sign their health insurance didn’t do what it’s supposed to—protect them from catastrophic financial risk. And for too many Americans, it doesn’t.

