I’ll start with a number that surprised me. A September 2026 KFF poll found that 66% of the public favors a single government plan that covers all Americans, the highest KFF has recorded since it began asking in 2016. About seven in ten independents now favor it, up from under six in ten six years ago. TThis isn’t a fringe idea anymore. It’s what a lot of people are quietly hoping for when they open a medical bill and feel their stomach drop. So why does it feel so far away?
The people who profit from the current system
Advocates of Medicare for All have a simple answer, and I think it deserves to be heard. Our health care system isn’t just a public service. It’s an enormous business, and many large companies make a lot of money from how things work today. Insurers, drug makers, and hospital systems all have a stake in keeping it that way.
A single national plan would change the math for all of them. If one program covers everyone, there’s no need for thousands of different plans, each with its own paperwork, networks, and denial letters. Supporters argue that this complexity is exactly where much of the money goes, and that someone’s overhead is always someone else’s revenue.
Then there’s the lobbying. Drug and health product companies have spent more on lobbying than any other industry every year since 1999. In an earlier fight over this idea, insurers, drug companies, and hospitals joined forces in a coalition, the Partnership for America’s Health Care Future. Its members reported spending $143 million lobbying Congress in 2018 alone.
I’ll be honest about the limits here. Most of the detailed reporting on that coalition dates from 2019 and 2020, and I couldn’t find fresh 2026 reporting on a specific new campaign. But the incentives haven’t changed, and neither has the playbook. When a reform threatens revenue, the people earning that revenue tend to show up.
The part where I don’t want to cheat
Here’s what advocates sometimes skip. Support for Medicare for All is real, but it’s soft. When KFF told respondents the plan would eliminate private insurance, support dropped to 52%. Sixty-one percent of respondents said it would raise their taxes. And the Axios-Ipsos poll found a much more cautious picture. It showed 43% in support, 24% opposed, and 32% unsure.
That tells me the fight won’t be won on slogans. It will be won by explaining, in plain language, that a tax increase could replace premiums, deductibles, and surprise bills. That’s the argument supporters make, and it’s a fair one to put in front of voters.
So what now?
If you’re one of those two-thirds, the most useful thing you can do is stay curious and stay loud. Ask candidates where they actually stand. Ask what happens to premiums, what happens to taxes, and who pays for what. And notice who profits when the answer stays vague.
The other side
Since this post argues one side, here is what critics say:
- Cost and taxes. Opponents point to estimates putting the price tag in the tens of trillions of dollars over a decade. They argue the taxes needed would be far larger than supporters admit.
- Disruption. Many people like their current coverage, and ending private insurance would disrupt it for a large share of the country.
- Wait times and access. Critics warn that a single payer could lead to delays in care, and that lower payments to providers could strain hospitals.
- Industry isn’t the only opposition. Plenty of voters, economists, and policymakers oppose it on policy grounds, not because of lobbying money. Many prefer incremental options like a public option or a Medicare buy-in.
- Polling caveat. Support swings a lot depending on how the question is worded, so a headline number doesn’t settle the debate.
Sources:

