The report’s central message is that healthcare professionals still have substantial influence, but they no longer have a monopoly on health authority. Patients operate in an information environment filled with family, peers, social media creators, AI, online research, and other sources. That competition is changing how people make health decisions.
Key Findings:
- Doctors remain strongest where the stakes are traditionally medical. Among people influenced by the respective sources, HCPs substantially outperform uncredentialed sources for diagnosis (50% vs. 23%) and long-term treatment (34% vs. 18%). But uncredentialed sources have greater influence over diet/nutrition (41% vs. 33%) and wellness/longevity (35% vs. 26%).
- A doctor’s recommendation is no longer automatically decisive. Among respondents who had received conflicting recommendations from a doctor and another source, only 51% said they always followed the doctor’s recommendation. Another 34% said it depended on the situation, while 15% always followed the other source.
- Credentials matter—but they’re not enough. Formal academic training from a trusted institution ranked highest as a marker of a legitimate health expert (71%). But respondents also valued whether someone’s advice had helped them previously (64%), personal experience with health problems (62%), and endorsement from trusted people (59%).
- AI is rapidly challenging traditional perceptions of expertise. Nearly half—49%—believe someone proficient with AI can perform at least one of four healthcare tasks as well as or better than a trained HCP. That rises to 59% among ages 18–34, versus 35% among people 55+. The individual tasks include triage (26%), determining treatment/medication (19%) and diagnosis (16%).
- Uncredentialed health influencers are filling an emotional and communication gap. Thirty-two percent say people without formal health credentials significantly influence their health decisions. What those sources provide that credentialed experts don’t is led by empathy, personal experience, understanding of demographic health needs, understandable language and accessibility.
- Health beliefs aren’t explained simply by politics or education. The report finds what it calls “divisive health beliefs” across age groups, political orientations and levels of science education. Overall, 70% believe at least one of six claims tested by Edelman; 29% believe three or more.
- More information may actually be diluting medical authority. People with three or more divisive beliefs report being influenced by an average of six sources, compared with three among people holding none. Doctor influence remains high (80% in both groups), but AI influence rises from 13% to 46%, and influence from creators without medical training rises from 9% to 45%.
- Conflicting information is strongly associated with these beliefs. Among people holding no divisive beliefs, 29% reported receiving conflicting recommendations from an HCP and another trusted source in the previous year. That jumps to 71% among people holding three or more. Importantly, the survey demonstrates an association; it does not establish that conflicting information caused those beliefs.
- Some patients are actively overriding medical advice. Among those with three or more divisive beliefs, 52% reported disregarding HCP guidance in favor of friends or family and 47% in favor of social media during the prior 12 months. Among those holding none, the figures were 15% and 10%, respectively.
The most important takeaway
The report argues that the solution isn’t simply more medical information or more forceful persuasion. Patients with doubts want HCPs to listen first, welcome questions without judgment, acknowledge concerns and understand the patient’s circumstances. For example, 58% say listening first to understand them and their life situation would be very or critically important when they have doubts about an HCP recommendation.
That makes the report particularly consequential for pharma and healthcare communications. Scientific authority remains necessary, but authority by itself is increasingly insufficient. The competitive advantage is shifting toward combining credible evidence with empathy, relevance, accessibility and genuine dialogue.
In other words: patients haven’t necessarily stopped listening to doctors. They’ve started listening to many other people at the same time.

