Healthcare: the availability of unlimited profits is a powerful motivating force

KEY TAKEAWAY: [inlinetweet prefix=”” tweeter=”” suffix=””]Healthcare is now the single biggest sector of the US economy.[/inlinetweet] It is bigger than big oil, bigger than big banking, and bigger even than the famous military-industrial complex that President Dwight Eisenhower warned about in his farewell speech. In 2013, the most generous estimate pegged the price of the military-industrial complex at $ 1.3 trillion, while healthcare expenditures in 2015 were $ 3.2 trillion, consuming nearly one of every five dollars spent in the US.

Over the past two generations— since the late 1960s—[inlinetweet prefix=”” tweeter=”” suffix=””] American healthcare has gradually been transformed from a relatively modest professional endeavor ruled mainly by traditional ethical norms governing independent doctors into a vast network of institutions dominated by for-profit corporations whose chief loyalty is to their shareholders and nonprofit organizations[/inlinetweet] that function much as for-profit entities do.

Today, like big oil and big banking, the medical-industrial complex has become so vast, so wealthy, and so powerful that it is increasingly insulated from the effects of its own errors and misdeeds. Virtually every major drug and medical device company has been caught in one or more scandals, and they pay massive fines as part of the cost of doing business.

Three historical developments lie at the center of the rise of the medical-industrial complex: the explosion of medical technology beginning in the 1960s; the passage of Medicare in 1965, along with the proliferation of private health insurance; and the Bayh-Dole Act of 1980. Together, these three developments drove the corporatization of medicine, with profound implications for the way healthcare is promoted, practiced, and regulated in the US.

One of the most powerful and rapidly growing participants in this burgeoning economic network is the medical device industry. Generating estimated revenues of more than $ 136 billion in the US in 2014, the implantable-device industry is even more lucrative for many of its component companies than the highly profitable pharmaceuticals industry.

Operating-profit margins for the largest companies include 30.0 percent for Zimmer Biomet (artificial joints), 28.6 percent for Medtronic, 25.8 percent for St. Jude Medical, and 23.1 percent for Stryker (orthopedic implants).

Johnson & Johnson’s device division squirreled away $ 7.2 billion in profits in 2012, while Medtronic pulled down $ 3.6 billion in profits that year.  Ultra-high prices help fuel those giant profit margins: Medtronic charges approximately $ 19,000 for a neurostimulator used to treat back pain, which is four times what it costs to manufacture the device. Hospitals pay $ 4,500– $ 7,500 for a popular type of hip implant that costs $ 350 to manufacture.  Hospitals are asked to sign confidentiality agreements, obliging them not to reveal their purchase prices.

[inlinetweet prefix=”” tweeter=”” suffix=””]In 2015, approximately sixteen thousand deaths associated with medical devices were reported to the FDA[/inlinetweet]. And a Government Accountability Office analysis found that [inlinetweet prefix=”” tweeter=”” suffix=””]99 percent of device-related “adverse events” are never reported to the FDA [/inlinetweet]and that the “more serious the event, the less likely it was to be reported.” [inlinetweet prefix=”” tweeter=”” suffix=””]Based on the GAO analysis, that means medical devices could have been associated with as many as 1.6 million deaths in 2015[/inlinetweet]. Even if only 1 to 10 percent of those deaths were caused by a device, that means between 16,000 and 160,000 people may have been killed by devices, making medical devices one of the leading causes of death in the US.

[inlinetweet prefix=”” tweeter=”” suffix=””]Walmart tracks every single head of lettuce it buys and sells and can determine how many heads of lettuce are on its shelves at any given moment, yet no one— not the FDA, not Brookings, not anyone— can say how many people are dying because of implanted medical devices. It’s a black hole.[/inlinetweet]